That is if the filming ever comes at all now. If they are allowed to terminate the rights to the Hobbit, then we’re at checkmate. Maybe someone other than New Line might pick it up if the Tolkien Estate wins. Then again, what are the chances that the judge will let them terminate the movie rights?
why don’t they just stop doing this to us?! first pj now tolkien estate… why don’t they relize that there are lotr fans who are going to be upset! and they decide to sue them now that they have agreed to make hobbit films! it’s not fair! :/ i hope everything gets settled soon adnd without any problems. i understand that is not fair to tolkien estate also but… realy… :/
Yeah, unfortunatly the Hobbit movies could be at risk…such a big sue could place New Line back down where it used to be, making small scale movies instead of large ones such as LOTR or the Hobbit:(
I don’t like lawsuits that could terminate any chance I have of seeing a live-action Hobbit, but at the same time, if New-Line agreed to pay royalties to the Estate, I think they should honor the agreement…The Estate controls the right to decide who can or cannot use Sindarin/Quenya, and Peter Jackson probably had to get permission before he could even have it scripted and for the Elves. He makes a trilogy that the Estate would feel held true to Tolkien’s vision, and New Line has to go and screw it all up by not sharing the wealth…Sigh…
Someone said that if New Line loses this lawsuit The Hobbit movies would probebly be made anyway – by some other movie company but in that case Peter Jackson would be able to be the director.
It will still be pretty much impossible for Pete to direct the Hobbit. He’s having scheduling difficulties that could only be solved by waiting even longer to start production. I don’t mind the idea of Del Toro directing, with Pete as an executive producer. I think Guillermo would stay true to the fantasy aspect while still making it very realistic.
15 responses to “Tolkien Estate Sues New Line Cinema”
not again!
*sigh* All this legal stuff is souring the legacy of PJ’s masterpieces and slowing the Hobbit’s momentum…
Aw man. I thought they would have figured all this stuff out before they even started filming.
That is if the filming ever comes at all now. If they are allowed to terminate the rights to the Hobbit, then we’re at checkmate. Maybe someone other than New Line might pick it up if the Tolkien Estate wins. Then again, what are the chances that the judge will let them terminate the movie rights?
why don’t they just stop doing this to us?! first pj now tolkien estate… why don’t they relize that there are lotr fans who are going to be upset! and they decide to sue them now that they have agreed to make hobbit films! it’s not fair! :/ i hope everything gets settled soon adnd without any problems. i understand that is not fair to tolkien estate also but… realy… :/
It’s always about the money.
Hopefully it will be less wanky then the currently running lawsuit against RDR Books.
*hopes for the best*
Hopefully it will be less wanky then the currently running WB lawsuit against RDR Books.
*hopes for the best*
Yeah, unfortunatly the Hobbit movies could be at risk…such a big sue could place New Line back down where it used to be, making small scale movies instead of large ones such as LOTR or the Hobbit:(
I don’t like lawsuits that could terminate any chance I have of seeing a live-action Hobbit, but at the same time, if New-Line agreed to pay royalties to the Estate, I think they should honor the agreement…The Estate controls the right to decide who can or cannot use Sindarin/Quenya, and Peter Jackson probably had to get permission before he could even have it scripted and for the Elves. He makes a trilogy that the Estate would feel held true to Tolkien’s vision, and New Line has to go and screw it all up by not sharing the wealth…Sigh…
Good greif, again?
Like I say, there is someone over there with WAY too much time on his hands.
Someone said that if New Line loses this lawsuit The Hobbit movies would probebly be made anyway – by some other movie company but in that case Peter Jackson would be able to be the director.
It will still be pretty much impossible for Pete to direct the Hobbit. He’s having scheduling difficulties that could only be solved by waiting even longer to start production. I don’t mind the idea of Del Toro directing, with Pete as an executive producer. I think Guillermo would stay true to the fantasy aspect while still making it very realistic.
But who knows what will come of all of it now.